Why Your Redesign Failed: Fixing Strategy Before UI

By ODW Media Room Best Practices 2025

In 2022, a major education platform in South Africa spent thousands redesigning their dashboard:

    New icons
    New fonts
    New layout

Everyone loved how it “looked”…
…until engagement dropped 27%.

Why?
Because the design was based on internal opinions, not user needs.

Users didn’t want a better layout.
They wanted faster access to their next class.

The redesign fixed the surface —
but not the experience.

Great design isn’t how it looks.
Great design is how it works for users.

The Cost of UI-Only Redesigns

MistakeImpact
Changes in familiar patterns Users feel lost
Pretty but unclear screens Drop-offs increase
Zero research Wrong decisions
Focus on trends No business impact

Users don’t stay for aesthetics.
They stay for clarity + outcome.

Strategy Before Screens: The Smart Way

Use this simple checklist before redesigning:

01

Define Primary User Job

The real goal (not what teams assume)

Example: “Book appointment in 2 taps” instead of “View all features”

02

Audit Behavior, Not Just UI

Pull real data: where users quit?

Analytics reveals truth designers can’t guess

03

Prototype Small Fixes First

Test micro changes

Less risky, more learning

04

Validate With Real Users

Ask them… watch them

Intent ≠ behavior

05

Measure Business KPIs

Does it make money, retain, or delight better?

Beauty without results is decoration

A Redesign Should Deliver Outcomes

If it doesn’t → undo.

Winning Formula

Strategy → UX → UI → Validate → Scale

UI is step 3
not step 1.

Case Study

Beauty without results is decoration

Client

Challenge

ODW Fix Strategy

10-Week Wins

OutcomeImpact
Report completion time –64% faster
Daily login frequency +27%
User satisfaction score Major improvement
Admin support tickets –32%

They didn’t need new colors.
They needed a new logic.

Final Thought

Design without strategy is just decoration.
Design with strategy drives revenue.

Let’s redesign what actually matters.

At ODW, creativity is our language and technology our voice — together, they build connections that matter.

© 2016-2026 Our Designs Work Inc. All right reserved.